Tembe and Nkorho Cams are down. We are working on solutions.

Compassion vs. Instinct

Anonymous's picture
Compassion vs. Instinct

As the miracle of life unfolded on the Black Eagle Cam, little did we know our viewing would be cut short due to a strange and confusing event.  The Black Eagle Project at Roodekrans has a very devoted and knowledgeable team working diligently to gather information and data on the great black eagle and its life. They have watched for years as a pair of adult eagles return to lay and raise a chick.  As part of the research, since 2006, the chicks have had identifcation tags and rings attached to their wings and legs in order to provide important information in their later lives. Unfortunately, during this season, the female adult eagle became very agitated that there was something foreign on the chick, the identification ring that was placed on the leg. In an effort to remove it from the chick, she accidentally broke its leg. As a result the chick has been removed and is recovering well, with hopes of a return to the wild in later months. So what was so important that the chick had to be tagged and ringed...why didn't we just let nature take its course?  Unfortunately over the years,  mankind has managed to invade and in some cases diminish the habitat of many animals. The black eagles are victims of the encroaching developments around them, and have had trouble providing for their chicks in the past due to lack of prey. Gathering information allows researchers to determine if and how much the species is being affected, and hopefully provide possible ways to help keep the birds from suffering any further at the hands of man.  That being said...we now come to the emotions that humans assume are felt by all animals.  As mammals, there is a very strong instinct to protect our young, to the death if necessary. We see it on all the animal documentary shows as a lone animal with a brand new calf or cub has to fight off the hungry leopard or lion. Our hearts are touched by the determination of the mother to keep her baby from being taken.  Birds on the other hand, while they are protective of their young, they are not capable of the same bond that mammals have.  When the black eagle chick was removed from the nest, the parents were confused, but accepted it and moved on.  There was perhaps confusion as to where the chick had gone, but not panic or desperation that mammals feel. The operate strictly on instinct...not emotion. Was it sad to watch? For us yes.  Was it distressing for the parent birds? Not in the same way it was for us. Were they coldhearted and uncaring? Not in the world of birds...they did exactly what they should have done, they laid two eggs...one survived, the other did not develop and the remains were most likely eaten by one of the adults.  How horrible you say? No...they were acting on instinct, insuring that the strongest chick would survive..not something a mammal would do. We see it often in the bird world..if a chick hatches and is weaker than the rest or something is wrong, the parents kick it out of the nest, or it is eaten, by either the siblings or an adult. Is it still hard to watch even knowing they act instinctively? Of course it is...simply because we think in terms of love and emotion, something birds cannot do.  While our viewing time has come to an end for this season, it was not a failure in the bird world. The chick was healthy before his leg was broken, and the surgery to repair it was too. He will be watched and cared for, eventually being released to continue his life as a great Black Eagle, and someday will be raising his own chicks from year to year.  If something happens to one along the way, he will accept it and move on with no feelings of remorse or distress, returning the next year to raise another. So while we say goodbye to our viewing for the year, it was not a failure, or an emotional let down, it was nature...pure and simply...it was nature.




Ballard's picture

Thanks for bringing

Thanks for bringing

Jenette's picture

I think this is

I think this is heartbreaking! Once again humans interfere and the animals suffer and at the end of the day it was for our benefit so that we can track and also watch them on our computers.  It's really not worth it and I hope that there is a lesson to be learnt here, don't interfere, let nature take it's course.


rosie105's picture

Really sorry to disagree

Really sorry to disagree with you!  But I dont agree it was nature totally - nature would not have included ringing or tagging.  Yes, nature would have caused the mother eagle to panic when she saw something on her chick's leg and react as an eagle would - that is nature.  And though, I understand the desire to monitor and follow progress after leaving the nest, I just feel that it is a shame that a young bird has had such a needlessly bad start in life.  It is not nature that the young eagle has to be hand reared - this would be understandable in the case of an accident.  I shall still continue to enjoy your wonderful site and look in every day to see what has happening, but I do feel sad about this incident.



Ranger Tales's picture

Thanks for bringing the to

Thanks for bringing the to our attention, the information has been edited. And thank you for reading!Smile

Birdsie Raptor's picture

"Tag...placed on the leg" 

"Tag...placed on the leg" 

I think the author may have meant a "ring" or a "band" was on the chick's leg rather than a tag.  I believe the tags were attached to the wings.

nickgriffin's picture

Very well done as

Very well done as always...and thanks

Nick Griffin

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.